Відео

There are a few depictions of men with buttoned hoods in Guiron le Courtois. The BNF Nouvelle aquistion frascaise 5243 Guiron le Courtois folio 75r has two examples, and I can think that there may be a few other images in that manuscript.

Nga Mihi, glad you enjoyed it. The helmet does have a visor but I didn't include it in the video because I couldn't get a clear shot of the inside. I bought the helmet secondhand from Piotr's Historical Workshop he's on Facebook.

@@PopulaUrbanum thanks for the reply!

No worries, good luck with your projects

That's a great video idea, I'll add it to the list :)

I have The Origins of the Corporation, it is sitting shamefully on my shelf at the moment. I find the root of economics and trade and its relationship to human cultures and history inseparable. Even as early as the Paleolithic, or earlier ( since that is not my wheelhouse) humanity has been trading commodities, war and politics were maybe developed to facilitate trade not the other way around?

@@PopulaUrbanum the primary focus of economics is production, consumption, and exchange. so yes, it is the root of all history. Even back before civilization as we know it came to be there were still those 3 elements at play. And it is impossible for war and politics to exist without economics. The very creation of an armed force, no matter how small, primitive, or temporary, is an economic process.

Right, Adam Smith asserted that a unregulated market will create competition and this competition will drive self regulation as poor products would be driven out of business, so it should not be restricted by regulation. Instead believing that consumers would somehow not buy inferior products instead of the market just being flooded by cheap inferior products. He saw one of the evils of the guilds as self regulating therefore interfering in free market forces. Guilds on the other hand knew that poor products resulted in poor business and loss of reputation and profits so sought to self regulate.

@@PopulaUrbanum and Smith’s ideas quickly brought upon what Twain termed the Gilded Age. I’d say Smith was way off on his assessment. And great video by the way, thank you

There are many sensible criticisms to be made about guilds and guild production, I agree that Smith's assessment on reliance on the so called invisible hand has not panned out. Glad you liked the video.

😂

What does that mean?

Off the top of my head I'd not be able to say what any statistics would be I'm afraid without rereading the sourced materials being that it was such a long time since writing this video. If I remember the use of the term "increase" was a writing attempt to move past a information dump in which I'd had multiple examples of secular school attendances increasing. Not the best way to share information I know. As for how evenly was education spread, while the wealthy did educate their children education was not relegated to an elite few, the middle class was active in setting up secular schools and creating charitable schools for poor children and girls. Likewise the rural workers received schooling from traveling scholars and priests who were paid to teach village children basic literacy and numeracy.

brilliant stuff, glad it is still helpful

It's Te Reo Maori, Kia Ora which has many meanings but in this case, means hello.

It's good to be back thank you. I view wealth or resource hoarding more of a symptom of unjust hierarchies, those at the top of the hierarchy hoard resources to maintain power because there is a material connection between power and those resources, money for the wealthy ceases to be about money for purchasing power and becomes a mechanism of exerting political or physical power. Greed is eating all the biscuits at the table, this is more than greed, it's about weilding political control. I'll let you draw your own conclusions on how I feel about power structures. As for videos we are still producing just not one a week, looking to focus more on quality than on quantity.

@@PopulaUrbanum Good point. Keeping the majority in debt is another still current way to maintain control- so one can see why userers have been disliked over and over. It's complicated I guess... And sure, quality is better- plus nobody wants quantity to cause people to burn out ;)

I'd disagree with you on that matter, the roots of antisemitism can be traced back to the classical period, while the term may be modern the ideas and practices of medieval Europe definitely informed modern antisemitism. It is reasonable to discuss the past with a modern lens because this is how we understand the world.

@@PopulaUrbanum racial politics is modern if you are talking about distrusting a certain worldview then shure but thats different and i feel like antisemitism doesnt really mean anything usefull anymore 1 because it doesnt make sense because most jews are turkic european or ethiopian and most semites arent jewish and 2 it like other words that had weight like racist etc got so overused on cases that dont match at all that the syndrome effect took over (ie if everyone is fill in the blank then no one is) i feel like anti jewish is a better term although that would also unfairly lump in those who have honest critiques of their worldview sorry for the block text not trying to be one of those people wish it could have been written shorter

This was such a difficult topic to write about, not only about the basis of credit, but the churches anti- usuary law and the Jewish lending, I really had to learn a lot about topics I only had a passing knowledge of for future videos. I do agree that the church does internally reform, sometimes it can be very dynamic and progressive other times slow and conservative. Does the existence of Christian lenders invalidate the objective immortality of usuary? I don't see it as a double standard or even see usuary as immoral since credit and lending predates capitalism and monied economies. I think the church was attempting to enshrine a system of lending more akin to Muslim lending, much of what was happening was political and warped up in the ideological. The other key here is much of Christian Europe did listen to the church, but at the same time ignored it, especially when the rules and laws became difficult to living their lives. Politically powerful people would often be excommunicated or censured for their crimes against the church and continue to live a happy life, even though no other Christian was supposed to do business with them only to make penance when it was politically expedient. For the common person who often had little contact with the priesthood would have more contact with lay preachers and engage in group worship. Laws and rules from the church had little impact on their lives and were mostly observances unless you lived on feudal lands ruled by the church. This is why orders like the Franciscans were important because they went amongst the people which is why specifically mention them in this. I'll say that I find the early years of their order fascinating, their attempts to reform the church in the during the late 1200's and engage in poverty relief will be key to an upcoming video. Don't get me wrong, this is not a critique of the church and was intended to be an objective statement of historic events.

@@PopulaUrbanum I think you did well to cover it in a short time, I just felt like a little pushback was necessary for healthy discourse

Absolutely agree with you, I appreciate the insight. I was really conscious of the megalithic nature of the church I had already cut 20 or so minutes off the script, so much gets lost in making these videos.

Thanks glad you enjoyed it.

I'll add it to the list then :)

isn't it?

Thank you, I grew it myself

Thank you, it's good to be back

Thanks, it's good to be back

I'll add it to the list :)

Really glad you enjoyed the video, it's good to be missed, but better to be back.

Who needs liquid assets? I want all my wealth in furnishings

good to be back, I am glad that the guild series was able to be useful to you.

Welcome, hope you enjoy :)

Thank you, its been awhile but we are glad to be back

great to be back

It's an interesting detail I think that is not much considered.

We are, it's been awhile we are a bit like punk, not dead just sleeping

Hey thanks for your support, it's good to be back and making videos again

Lots to cover, should this have been several videos?? Yes. Did I make this several videos? No.